Words, wires, and worms

Love Is a Four-Letter Word

“You never loved me!”

I didn’t answer back. At the time, I didn’t know how. The accusation wasn’t true, yet there was some truth in it.

I had loved my ex-husband, even in that moment, but my love wasn’t that our-hearts-beat-as-one love. The soulmate, I-can’t-live-without-you “true” love.

A side note: I’m not including in this tangle of thoughts love for children or parents or pets. This is about romantic love.

You never loved me!

I felt the raw pain in his accusation. After three children and more than fifteen years of marriage, there it was, this half-truth squatting uncomfortably on the shards of our relationship.

That moment haunted me for years. The untrue truth didn’t prompt the demise of our marriage (we had other problems), yet for years, I struggled with the notion that I had a defect in my love gears that made me incapable of “true” love.

Is true love a childish fantasy or daydream? I don’t think so. I know couples who have “true” love, who feel they are soulmates. At times, I felt envious. I compared myself and wondered, “Why can’t I have that? Am I broken?”

In an effort to untangle the nature of my love mechanism and hoping to find out what was broken, I committed quite a bit of thought and energy to these questions.  I looked in, but I also looked out.

Looking out, I became aware that assumptions often made about “true” love and other relationships fall apart on scrutiny. Couples who feel they are soulmates are not without their ups and downs and missteps. Even soulmates must work on right relationship. Couples who don’t fancy themselves soulmates can enjoy depth of commitment and compassion. Old solid relationships may still have embarrassing middle-school moments, and budding ones often work through hurdles with maturity and wisdom.


My parents paddling into the 60th year of their journey

Looking out, I confirmed what I already knew: romantic love comes in many sizes, shapes, and tones.

Looking in, I started defining the expectations I had going into a relationship and understanding the qualities I wanted in a partner and partnership. Pretty damn practical. Share in all things domestic, complete projects together yet have projects of our own, communicate with compassion and patience, journey together and journey apart. My list did not include requisites such as “must be my soulmate” or “I would die without him.”

The observations and introspection helped me understand that I wasn’t broken at all. Perhaps I guard my heart, perhaps my love is not “true” love as conceived by many. Yet I would argue that my love is true.

Explain? OK. I love my partner of nine years. I’m still working on domestic equity, but we share, we fuss, we communicate, we have projects, we take trips, and we have independent interests and endeavors. We’re not soulmates, but our love is good. True love? I would say that my love is true, but I would hasten to point out that, if he were to die tomorrow, I would be sad, deeply sad. I would mourn and grieve. But I would not be devastated or feel lost. Is that because he’s not my soulmate? Is it because I guard my heart? I’m not sure what the answer is. I do believe, however, that the “trueness” of my love should not be measured by my dependence on the presence of that person.

For those who would accuse me of settling for a partner I can love instead of waiting for the soulmate I can’t live without, let me assure you I didn’t settle, I chose. We chose each other. That said, I’m not writing this for those doubters. I’m writing this for the other people like me, who, at some point wondered if they were getting it all wrong, if they were incapable of true love, if they were broken because they couldn’t surrender their hearts with abandon.

While we can make generalizations about love, define it, classify it, even qualify it, those intellectual exercises confuse the love we live. I don’t believe in hard edges that define where you cross into or out of true love. Instead of ideals and definitions, I would have been better served as a young adult by this kind of advice:

  • Don’t chastise yourself if your love doesn’t fit a standard definition.
  • Observe others in love but don’t belittle your love for being different.
  • Your unique love journey should start from within, loving yourself, understanding your expectations and needs.
  • Be true to yourself and your love will be true.

My ex was a little right but mostly wrong. I did love him. In some ways I still do.

In the end, no matter what size, shape, or tone, love is love. Be true to it.

Copyright © 2015 by Pennie Nichols, All Rights Reserved.

12 responses

  1. Paula Kiger (Big Green Pen)

    Oh my goodness this is SO. PERFECT. And so fitting for me. I have had two therapists, after I explain my relationship (of 23 years marriage/five years dating prior) call my spouse “a sperm donor.” UM, NO. Nope nope nope. (And I haven’t really gotten up the nerve to write about it in my blog because I just think it could be considered hurtful by several people). Therefore, thank you for giving voice to a question many of us undoubtedly ask ………


    October 12, 2015 at 12:48 pm

    • It took me a long time to build up the courage to voice it. But I knew I wasn’t the only one. You’re welcome, and thanks.


      October 12, 2015 at 12:53 pm

  2. What works for some people doesn’t work for others. It is hard not to be judgmental with ourselves. I had 2 friends loose their husbands to illness this year and their grieving and moving on has been opposite to each other. Another example of different coping and emotional ways for different people.


    October 12, 2015 at 1:23 pm

  3. leannelc

    I think we have turned “soul mates” into some sort of nirvana and no love is enough unless we have some sort of undying spiritually exclusive high all the time. To me, enduring and committed love is what counts – being prepared to stick it out and stay connected through thick and thin is so much more real than Romeo and Juliet. Great post 🙂


    October 12, 2015 at 1:27 pm

    • Sticking it out and staying connected usually has happier endings than Romeo and Juliet as well! 🙂


      October 12, 2015 at 1:29 pm

  4. Jennifer Minnick

    Insightful stuff. I can relate a lot to your experience with your ex-husband.

    My husband and I divorced last year after almost 25 years of marriage. I knew deep down that, while I cared about him very much, I didn’t “LOVE” him. I even suspected that he didn’t really “LOVE” me. But we did love each other in our own ways, and we were both happy and content for many years. We raised 2 wonderful children, and we still care about each other. We are like really good old friends. But the truth was, I was in love with someone from my past. Someone I loved so much that giving in to it at the time scared me. Which is why we didn’t end up together.

    Fast forward a quarter of a century later…I have reunited with that long lost love, and I am now happier than I’ve ever been. It feels like a great wrong has been righted. Like a missing piece of me has been found. (not sure if these means we are soul-mates, or just that our love was cut off prematurely and not able to run it’s normal course).

    But I don’t regret those 25 years with my Ex. And my current partner and I have discussed in length our earlier relationship. We both agree that at the time neither of us were mature enough to make our relationship last. And we are both bringing into our current relationship lessons we learned from our failed marriages.

    Love, like faith, can not be quantified. No one can dictate how real your love is or how true your faith is based on what they see.


    October 12, 2015 at 2:22 pm

  5. At age 60, I now see how much our definition of love evolves over a lifetime. I loved my ex-husband when I married him 20 years ago, but then I learned how to love myself better. When that happened I had to let him go.
    I believe I found my soulmate at age 49, and ten years later I feel even stronger about that. I trust him with my heart, my soul and my life. I know this does not happen to most people, and that makes it seem even more precious.


    October 12, 2015 at 3:32 pm

  6. Love is so hard to define, especially for ourselves. The main thing, I guess, is to just make sure the love you share is good for both you and your partner and enhances both your lives.


    October 12, 2015 at 4:12 pm

  7. I’ve been married for 47 years and when I tell someone that I add, ‘7 years of wedded bliss, not necessarily consecutive.’ I lived through multiple marriages/ relationships with my mother. She was always quick to leave after the first big fight. Leaving was more painful than working it out, in my opinion. No one lives in bliss for long. I’m glad I learned from her mistakes and stuck it out with my husband through good and bad.


    October 12, 2015 at 4:22 pm

  8. I’ve had a long relationship where I loved him, but he wasn’t the end all, be all. He was Mr. Right Now, and I knew he felt the same about me. My relationship with my late husband James was one of those once in a lifetime loves. His death devastated me. Question: Does your current nine year relationship know how you feel? Has he read this blog? I’m just wondering how HE feels about your admission.


    October 13, 2015 at 2:33 pm

    • Thanks for the comment and the question. Yes. I shared my blog with my partner before I posted it. I think he would like to believe we are soulmates, so I think there was a little sadness. But our relationship has been built on frankness, honesty, and candor, as well as tenderness and complicity. I think he appreciates that I can talk to him about this.


      October 13, 2015 at 2:44 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s